The Right is criticising the release of
Bush Administration Terror Memos, claiming once again, that those who don't share their views or actions counter to their views are aiding & abetting Al Qaeda terrorists.
Just the same old, tiresome argument that has been completely discredited by
Cheney and other neocon fabricators of the same ilk. This 'helping terrorists' argument has been employed in attempts to discredit criticism of the
War in Iraq and to
disparage the
closing of Guantanamo Bay. They are, in reality, claiming any opposition to their ideas, their policy,
to them, is aiding and abetting the enemy. Apparently, anyone who opposes them
is their enemy.
George Will, on
This Week, suggested that other, unnamed nations, will be harmed as well as us, by the release of these memos. Guess George has a Top Secret clearance and can't tell which nations. Otherwise he'd have to… torture us.
Chief of Staff Rahm Emanuel responded to this nonsense on ABC's
This Week by asserting the purpose of the memo release – to expose abhorrent practices, to affirm America's commitment to refrain from torture. His position on 'aiding & abetting' was that such an argument was moot - these "enhance interrogation techniques" are now prohibited by executive order and thus reading about them will be of no use to Al Qaeda.
David Axelrod, Senior Advisor to President Obama, relayed on
Face the Nation that the particular enhanced interrogation techniques discussed in the memos has been
in the public record for months, years.
Show me the data! Where's the evidence that Al Qaeda has or will use any such data to train their operatives? Think these Qaeda thugs don't know a lot already about torture? Think they train the same way the Navy Seals do? C'mon boys, who's naive now?
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was waterboarded 183 times in March 2003 and Abu Zubaydah was waterboarded 83 times in August 2002. ~emptywheel Blog
Hmm… I thought the Neocon argument for torture was that it was an effective intelligence tool. I think even the
fictional character, Jack Bauer, might get a clue from that number –183 waterboardings in a month isn't an "
enhanced interrogation technique".
It's revenge. It's sadism. It's torture.